Google Reviews

Hidden jem. Had a fantastic sandwich on fresh made bread.

I didn’t find the service friendly. The Navy Bean soup, no flavor, small portions. The sandwich dry, and small. The inside was dark and dreary almost. Go to Fish Creek Market for sandwiches , piled high sandwiches, tons of ingredients, comes with chips and a cookie, the owners takes pride in their sandwich making, reasonably priced too! Skip this Macready place…

Went with family on a random Sunday, and was pleasantly surprised! LGBTQ+ friendly, terrific service, and great bread! Would recommend!

We were in Door County a couple of weeks ago, and stopped at MacReady Artisan Bread Company our first day there. We loved it so much that we ended up eating breakfast or lunch there five out of our seven days in Door County, and took some bread home with us! Can’t say enough about how nice everyone was, and everything we tried was outstanding. Make sure to try their soups, my husband said their tomato parmesan soup is the best he’s ever had. I wish we were closer so we could go there more often; definitely a go-to place in Door County, you will not be disappointed!! Thanks Mike & Jenny!

I love that this father daughter duo work together to make such delicious bread and always stop in for a sandwich and a few loaves to bring home when I pass through town.

Love this bakery. Everyone is so friendly and it’s truly a family affair. Their scones & cherry bread are to die for! (Bread out of the oven around 10am). Headed back to Door County this weekend and I will be at Maccready’s several times a week.

Best sandwich & soup place in Door County. Amazing bread and quality ingredients.

Amazing, amazing bread. Seriously delicious. Anything other than the quality of the bread is unimportant.

Excellant dinner & cheese. Attentive service.