Testimonials

Best homemade bread, soups and sandwiches in all of Door County. Made with fresh homemade ingredients every day. My favorite tomato parmigiana soup and cranberry chicken salad sandwich. Recently tried the quiche and it was excellent. Need to make Egg Harbor a stop for lunch at Macreadys.

MacReady’s is one of our favorite places to go in Door County. The bread is amazing…fresh baked daily using the best ingredients. I am obsessed with Jenny’s Butter Crisp cookies but her Happy Hippie and Chocolate Chip are fabulous too. They offer the best sandwiches ever….cranberry chicken salad, egg salad, turkey and cheese and more and OF COURSE they are made with their fresh bread. The soups are amazing. My favorite is the Chicken with Wild Rice but all of the soups are wonderful. I highly recommend that you make a point of stopping at MacReady’s in Egg Harbor when you are in Door County…you will be SO glad that you did!

My friend and I stopped in here for coffee and a pastry and we left with freshly baked breads, scones and a local artist’s drawing! My friend and I each had a cherry scone (with butter) that was perfect and she had a coffee. We could smell amazing bread being baked and couldn’t resist buying loaves for later! There’s plenty of parking for the bakery’s location that’s visible from Highway 42. We met the owner and her mom and they were so welcoming to us tourists! The board with a breakfast and lunch menu looked really tempting, too!

Review as seen on TripAdvisor

We chose to look up this bakery because of the rave reviews from Trip Advisors. We got there a bit late as most of the fresh baked goods were sold out. But, we did get to have a very nice light lunch. The heirloom tomato & Farro soup was fresh, hot and delicious. My husband & I enjoyed the variety of breads that accompanied the soup. My son had a healthy portion of liverwurst sandwich (I forgot the German name).
Best of all, there were some breads on the day old shelf that I was able to buy and at a discount.
The owner was so friendly and helpful as I made my bread and lunch choices. We will definitely make a point to visit this bakery on our next trip to Door County!

Review as seen on TripAdvisor

It was our last day of our vacation, and we were looking for something light. We wanted to kill two birds with one stone by finding a good bread place and a good olive oil place, so we picked Macready’s because of it’s proximity to another store we were going to for olive oil.

The cranberry chicken salad sandwich was so good. I had a half sandwich with a bowl of the chicken and rice soup, and it was very filling! We picked up some scones and cookies to go, as well.

There was live music in the gazebo outside that completed the pleasant meal. Will definitely return again in the future!

Review as seen on TripAdvisor