MacReady’s is one of my absolute favorite stops in Door County! My husband and I discovered it on our honeymoon in 2012 and I’ve been multiple times with my friends on girls’ trips. Today my kids also gave it 5 stars! All of the bread is amazing and the cookies are fantastic. We also love the egg salad which can be so hard to get right. Stop here if you are a bread lover or are looking for a great, simple sandwich.